Universal Studios sued Sony for copyright infringement in 1976. They alleged that Sony was responsible for developing a technology that some consumers might use for copyright infringement purposes. The District Court ruled that the non-commercial practice of home recording was fair use of copyrighted works, and it did not constitute copyright infringement. Further, the court deduced that Sony couldn’t be held liable for contributory infringement, even if the home use of VCRs was considered copyright infringement. Sony won the lawsuit, and it seemed like the practice of home recording would persist. However, in 1981, the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed the decision and held Sony liable for contributory infringement.
In 1983, the Betamax case, formally called Sony Corporation of America v. Universal City Studios, Inc., was brought to the Supreme Court. In a 5-4 decision, the court ruled in favor of Sony. This meant that the sale of Betamax video tape recorders to the public did not violate the Copyright Act and did not constitute contributory infringement. Justice John Paul Stevens wrote that, "[t]he sale of copying equipment...does not constitute contributory infringement if the product is widely used for legitimate, unobjectionable purposes, or, indeed, is merely capable of substantial noninfringing uses." In the dissenting minority opinion, Justice Blackmun expressed that taping copyrighted work was infringement, and recorder manufacturers were guilty of inducing the infringement.
Although Betamax ultimately lost the videotape format war to VHS recorders, the case legitimized noncommercial home recording and revolutionized the way that films were consumed. Studios ended up benefiting from the ruling because their films started being watched so much more. Without the Betamax ruling, even the digital video recorder (DVR) systems that many use today would have been illegal to produce.
I think that it is interesting that the decision for the Supreme Court case was so close and easily could have gone a different way. Everything would be a lot different since VHS recorders and home recording was so influential. Also some of the film industries concerns are still relevant today as there is a multitude of pirated content on the internet.
ReplyDelete